
From the Clouds to the Resistance
1979

Representation Score
Excellent
2014
Director
Jean-Marie Straub
Runtime
70 minutes
Average Rating
No ratings yetNew Showbiz Analysis
Jean-Marie Straub’s *Kommunisten* is an experimental film that replaces character-driven stories with linguistic and ideological structures. It challenges Western dominance by using multiple languages and avoiding traditional narratives. However, its abstract nature makes it hard to represent specific identities like disability, race, or gender. The film excels in cultural and political critique but lacks the character depth needed for traditional diversity measures.
Category Breakdown
The film uses text blocks instead of showing romantic relationships between characters. It avoids typical assumptions about straight relationships but doesn't show any specific LGBTQ+ identities or intimate moments.
By focusing on philosophical texts rather than individual characters, the film avoids reinforcing traditional ideas about male leadership or domestic roles. Instead, it highlights collective movements rather than individual actions based on gender.
This work uses French, Italian, and German languages, moving away from an Anglo-centric viewpoint. However, it's hard to confirm specific racial casting.
The story focuses on anti-capitalist and materialist ideas through the works of Malraux and Fortini. It criticizes Western institutions and traditional views of progress.
The film presents the human experience through abstract time segments, making it hard to see how it addresses physical or neurological differences. The focus on text means there's less emphasis on specific bodily experiences.
Present on Screen
Limited or Absent
Official Synopsis
Jean-Marie Straub pushes this musicality of blocks to a paroxysmal extreme, mixing blocks of time (40 years separate the various extracts that are going to be used, and what is to be filmed), blocks of text (Malraux, Fortini, Vittorini, Hölderlin) and blocks of language (French, Italian, German), and from this ruckus emerges the history of the world, yes, History with a capital H, and from the same movement, the political hope of its being overtaken. So this is an adventure film, about the Human adventure, still one that is always, in the end, overtaken by Nature.

1979

1928

1967

1964

2010

1995

2004

1970
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts on this movie!
Use the rating form above to leave a star rating and optional review.