You are here:

No tan nuestras

Name: No tan nuestras
Director: Ramiro Longo
Released: 2005
Duration: 74 min

Representation Score

7.8/10

Good

2005

Director

Ramiro Longo

Runtime

74 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Ramiro Longo’s documentary offers a profound look at the human cost of the Falklands/Malvinas War. By focusing on the testimony of veteran Sergio Delgado, the film shifts away from traditional military chronicles to explore the systemic failures of the state and the lasting psychological impacts on its citizens. The work excels in its portrayal of mental health and its critique of nationalistic narratives. It challenges the 'invincible soldier' archetype by focusing on the vulnerability of men struggling with post-war life and the high rates of veteran suicide. While the film lacks explicit representation of LGBTQ+ identities or diverse ethnic groups, its strength lies in its deconstruction of official history. It offers a nuanced, systemic critique of how national identity is curated and maintained.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does No tan nuestras have LGBTQ+ representation?

Fair

The film does not explicitly mention LGBTQ+ characters or themes. Instead, it focuses on the experiences of veterans and the psychological trauma of war.

How does No tan nuestras portray gender?

Fair

The film highlights the masculine perspective on trauma and reintegration through the character of Sergio Delgado. It disrupts traditional clichés by emphasizing the vulnerability and fragility of male veterans.

How racially and ethnically diverse is No tan nuestras?

Fair

The documentary explores the formation of Argentine national identity by examining how official history is constructed. It touches on the inclusion or exclusion of voices within the national mythos.

How does No tan nuestras represent religion and culture?

Excellent

The film critiques institutional authority by contrasting personal testimonies with official history. It prioritizes lived truth over state-sanctioned patriotism and heroic sacrifice.

Does No tan nuestras include disability representation?

Good

The film provides significant depth on invisible disabilities, particularly mental health and PTSD. It treats psychological scars as central to the human condition.

Present on Screen

Provides a nuanced, non-idealized portrayal of masculinity through the lens of psychological vulnerability.
Offers deep, meaningful representation of invisible disabilities and the long-term effects of PTSD.
Critically examines the construction of official history and the systemic abandonment of veterans.

Limited or Absent

Lacks explicit representation or discussion of LGBTQ+ identities and themes.
Focuses on a specific demographic, offering limited visibility for diverse racial or ethnic perspectives.

Official Synopsis

The Falklands/Malvinas War has proved a powerful motif in contemporary Argentine film-making and Ramiro Longo's new documentary offers a unique take on the conflict and its pervasive legacy. While Argentina suffered 649 casualties during the War, subsequently over 350 ex-servicemen have committed suicide while attempting to come to terms with civilian life in the aftermath of the 1982 defeat. Longo's film is structured around an extended interview with War veteran Sergio Delgado who provides a moving testimony on the conflict and the ways in which it has subsequently haunted his life and aspirations. As much an insider's view of the conflict as a tale of the legacy of trauma, Not Really Ours offers a reflection on memory, fear and the shaping of a nation's psyche. Longo's deft editing juxtaposes telling footage alongside Delgado's story. The result is both a moving tapestry of war and its scars and a telling reflection on the ways in which official history is constructed.

How are these scores produced? →