You are here:

The Broken Star

Name: The Broken Star
Director: Lesley Selander
Released: 1956
Duration: 82 min

Representation Score

1.7/10

Minimal

1956

Approved

Director

Lesley Selander

Runtime

82 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

The Broken Star operates as a standard mid-century Western, adhering closely to the genre conventions of its time. While it moves beyond a purely Anglo-centric perspective by incorporating Mexican and Indigenous elements, it does not use these inclusions to challenge existing social hierarchies. The film relies on established archetypes, particularly regarding gender and morality. The protagonist's journey is defined by traditional masculine struggles, and the cultural friction presented lacks the complexity needed for a more progressive reading. Ultimately, the film serves as a baseline example of 1950s storytelling. It provides a modest level of ethnic variety but remains firmly rooted in the traditional frameworks of the era.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does The Broken Star have LGBTQ+ representation?

Minimal

The film does not include any LGBTQ+ characters or narratives. Romantic elements align strictly with the era's traditional heterosexual relationships.

How does The Broken Star portray gender?

Limited

Character dynamics reinforce traditional masculine roles of the protector and the wronged man. The narrative follows conventional mid-century gender hierarchies without challenging power dynamics.

How racially and ethnically diverse is The Broken Star?

Fair

The story includes Mexican and Native American elements through a murder investigation and refuge. However, these depictions remain constrained by the cinematic clichés of the 1950s.

How does The Broken Star represent religion and culture?

Fair

The film explores friction between institutional law and individual morality. It functions within the 'wronged man' cliché rather than critiquing Western hegemony or systemic structures.

Does The Broken Star include disability representation?

Minimal

There is no evidence of characters with visible or invisible disabilities being integrated into the narrative or portrayed with ability to act.

Present on Screen

The narrative incorporates Mexican and Native American elements, offering more ethnic variety than a standard frontier procedural.
The central conflict introduces moral complexity regarding the reliability of Western legal institutions.

Limited or Absent

The film reinforces traditional gender hierarchies and masculine archetypes without subversion.
Depictions of Indigenous and Mexican characters are limited by the era's cinematic clichés.
There is a complete lack of LGBTQ+ representation or characters with disabilities.

Official Synopsis

A deputy sheriff defies local ranchers to investigate a Mexican's murder.

How are these scores produced? →