
Same Old Song
1997

1993
Director
Alain Resnais
Runtime
280 minutes
Average Rating
No ratings yetSynopsis
Two actors portray eighteen Yorkshire villagers, who offer several iterations of their lives depending on whether or not they lit a cigarette at a certain point in time.
Overall Score
Fair
Category Breakdown
LGBTQ+ Representation
The film avoids explicit queer narratives or critiques of heteronormativity. However, its rejection of a fixed reality allows for interpersonal dynamics that bypass traditional constraints, offering a framework where non-normative identities can exist without being tethered to tropes.
Gender Representation
Resnais disrupts gender hierarchies by deconstructing stable characters. By presenting multiple iterations of the same individuals, the film strips away the ability to categorize characters through rigid, traditional social roles or domestic expectations.
Racial & Ethnic Diversity
The narrative centers on a specific Yorkshire-based ensemble. There is no evidence of significant racial or ethnic diversity within the primary cast or any visible attempt at diverse casting.
Religious & Cultural Diversity
The film excels in subverting Western epistemological certainties. It champions moral relativism and the subjectivity of truth, critiquing the concept of a 'grand narrative' through its fragmented, non-linear structure.
Disability Representation
The film explores the fragmentation of memory and perception metaphorically. It does not feature characters with visible or invisible physical or neurodivergent disabilities portrayed with specific agency.
Strengths
Areas for Improvement
AI Analysis
Smoking / No Smoking is a sophisticated exercise in postmodern narrative architecture. Rather than focusing on demographic variety, it achieves progressive value through intellectual subversion. It challenges the 'truth' of Western storytelling by replacing stable arcs with situational ethics. The film's primary contribution lies in its deconstruction of the objective observer. It promotes a worldview where identity and truth are fluid, multifaceted, and perpetually in flux, prioritizing subjective experience over singular, authoritative morality. While the film lacks traditional representation in terms of race and disability, its structural approach to identity provides a unique, if indirect, form of progressive engagement.

1997

2000

1939

2002

1952

1984

1998

2004

2018

2004

2004

2005
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts on this movie!
Use the rating form above to leave a star rating and optional review.