You are here:

Keeping the Kibbutz

Name: Keeping the Kibbutz
Director: Ben Crosbie, Tessa Moran
Released: 2010
Duration: 54 min

No Poster Available

Representation Score

5.3/10

Fair

2010

TV-G

Director

Ben Crosbie, Tessa Moran

Runtime

54 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Keeping the Kibbutz serves as a sociological study of a community in flux. It excels at examining the ideological shift from collectivism to individualism, providing a deep look at the decline of socialist institutions. This cultural critique provides the film's strongest diversity element. However, the film lacks visibility in several key areas. There is no evidence of LGBTQ+ representation or disability narratives. The racial and gender depictions appear tied to the specific historical and ethnic frameworks of the Israeli kibbutz, which limits broader multi-layered scope. Ultimately, the documentary is a specialized ethnographic work. While it offers meaningful insight into communal identity and systemic transition, it remains anchored in a specific socio-political context rather than a diverse, multi-faceted social spectrum.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Keeping the Kibbutz have LGBTQ+ representation?

Fair

The documentary does not explicitly mention LGBTQ+ characters or non-straight relationships. It focuses on nostalgia and dedicated members, suggesting a more traditional perspective on the kibbutz movement.

How does Keeping the Kibbutz portray gender?

Fair

The film explores a community undergoing change, touching on the shifting roles of men and women. It examines the tension between traditional labor and evolving women's roles within the communal structure.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Keeping the Kibbutz?

Fair

The narrative is rooted in specific Zionist and ethnic frameworks inherent to the Israeli kibbutz movement. It reflects a concentrated ethnic lens consistent with the historical and geographic context.

How does Keeping the Kibbutz represent religion and culture?

Good

The film provides a strong critique of Western capitalist structures by documenting the decline of collectivist ideals. It explores the friction between communalism and the pressures of privatization.

Does Keeping the Kibbutz include disability representation?

Minimal

There is no evidence regarding the portrayal of visible or invisible disabilities within the film's narrative.

Present on Screen

Provides a meaningful exploration of the tension between collectivist and individualist ideologies.
Offers a deep sociological critique of traditional social organizations and privatization.
Captures the historical transition of a specific communal movement with ethnographic focus.

Limited or Absent

Lacks visible representation of LGBTQ+ identities or queer narratives.
Provides no evidence of disability representation within the community.
The ethnic lens is concentrated within a specific historical and Zionist framework.

Official Synopsis

Chronicling the changing kibbutz through the eyes of some of its most devoted members, Keeping the Kibbutz is a feature length documentary (54 min) that examines the challenges faced by a community in transition. While some members faced heartbreak, others found new opportunities, and the kibbutz marched toward an inevitable end. A story about nostalgia, the effects of communal living and the hope for what lies ahead, Keeping the Kibbutz captures the lingering ghost of a movement left behind.

How are these scores produced? →