You are here:

Playback

Name: Playback
Director: Agustina Comedi
Released: 2019
Duration: 14 min

Representation Score

9.3/10

Excellent

2019

Director

Agustina Comedi

Runtime

14 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Playback is a powerful piece of restorative media that recovers a lost history. It shifts the focus from mainstream narratives to the multi-layered experiences of a underrepresented community in Córdoba. The film transforms archival footage into a critique of systemic exclusion, elevating queer identity from passive victimhood to active, creative resistance against political and religious oppression. While the film excels in addressing gender and sexual identity, it offers less clarity regarding racial diversity. Its focus on regional identity provides a necessary alternative to metropolitan-centric storytelling.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Playback have LGBTQ+ representation?

Excellent

The film focuses on the lives of transgender women and drag queens in the Grupo Kalas community. It highlights their creative expressions as tools of resistance during the HIV/AIDS crisis.

How does Playback portray gender?

Excellent

By highlighting women whose identities were scrutinized by state and religious institutions, the film challenges traditional hierarchies. It portrays gender performance as a sophisticated way to navigate a conservative society.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Playback?

Fair

The documentary offers a nuanced look at regional identity by centering the provincial experience of Córdoba. However, it does not provide specific details about the racial makeup of the group.

How does Playback represent religion and culture?

Excellent

The narrative critiques institutional power, presenting the Catholic Church as a force of oppression. It emphasizes communal survival and friendship over traditional religious morality.

Does Playback include disability representation?

Good

The film addresses the intersection of identity and health by documenting the impact of the AIDS epidemic. It handles the subjects' vulnerability with dignity, focusing on their ability to act and collective memory.

Present on Screen

Centers on the history of transgender women and drag queens.
Transforms archival footage into a critique of systemic exclusion.
Reclaims underrepresented historical narratives.
Challenges conservative social landscapes through gender performance.

Limited or Absent

Limited specific information about the racial composition of the subjects.
Focus remains heavily on gender and sexual identity over other multi-layered markers.

Official Synopsis

In Córdoba, far from the Argentine capital, the end of a military regime promises a spring that is all too brief. “La Delpi” is the only survivor of a group of friends who are transgender women and drag-queens, who began to die of aids in the late 80s. In a Catholic and conservative city, the Grupo Kalas made their weapons and trenches out of improvised dresses and lip-syncing. Today the images of unique and unknown footage are not only a farewell letter, but a manifesto to friendship.

How are these scores produced? →