You are here:

Und alle haben geschwiegen

Und alle haben geschwiegen

Representation Score

7.3/10

Good

2013

Director

Dror Zahavi

Runtime

90 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Dror Zahavi’s drama is a sophisticated exploration of collective memory and institutional failure. It succeeds by centering a survivor’s ability to act to challenge the silence of powerful religious and state structures in post-war Germany. The film’s strength lies in its cultural critique and its refusal to present a singular, authoritative truth. By using fragmented perspectives, it highlights how individual trauma intersects with systemic complicity. However, the film lacks breadth in other areas of representation. It offers little visibility for LGBTQ+ identities or multi-ethnic perspectives, remaining deeply focused on a specific German historical context.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Und alle haben geschwiegen have LGBTQ+ representation?

Limited

The film does not prominently feature LGBTQ+ characters or stories centered around non-straight identities. Instead, it focuses on broader societal issues without addressing specific queer narratives or critiques of the assumption that everyone is straight.

How does Und alle haben geschwiegen portray gender?

Fair

A female protagonist plays a significant role in driving the story as she returns to Germany to confront its institutional history. She acts as a moral authority against historically male-dominated institutions, although the interpersonal dynamics focus more on trauma than on gendered power structures.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Und alle haben geschwiegen?

Fair

The narrative is rooted in post-war German history and the experiences of German orphans. It focuses on the ethnic and social strata of Germany, showing little evidence of a diverse cast with different backgrounds.

How does Und alle haben geschwiegen represent religion and culture?

Excellent

The film excels by critiquing traditional Western institutions and the systemic abuse within Church organizations. It disrupts the portrayal of religious groups as benevolent, framing them instead as sites of oppression and silence.

Does Und alle haben geschwiegen include disability representation?

Fair

The story explores profound psychological trauma and the lasting effects of PTSD. These invisible disabilities are treated with narrative depth and ability to act rather than being used as mere plot devices.

Present on Screen

  • Strong cultural critique of religious and state institutions.
  • Provides a significant role in driving the story to a female protagonist confronting historical trauma.
  • Treats psychological trauma and PTSD with narrative depth and complexity.

Limited or Absent

  • Lacks visible representation of LGBTQ+ characters or queer narratives.
  • Limited racial and ethnic diversity within the German-centric setting.
  • Focus remains narrow on specific post-war German social strata.

Official Synopsis

Between 1949 and 1975 more than 800 000 German orphans have lived their post-war years in Church Institutions. They have endured terrible abuses. Everyone knew but no one spoke. In 2012 the Church admitted her wrongdoings. The movie tells the story of a German woman (Senta Berger) living in New York coming back to Germany to bear witness in front of a board of enquiry. During her stay she remembers her traumatic experience.

How are these scores produced? →

Where to Watch

Rate this Movie

No rating selected
Use arrow keys to select a rating from 1 to 5 stars
Optional text review, maximum 2000 characters
Tip: Wrap spoilers with ||double pipes|| to hide them
0/2000 characters
You must be signed in to submit a rating

Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts on this movie!

Use the rating form above to leave a star rating and optional review.