You are here:

The Butcher Baker: Mind of a Monster

Name: The Butcher Baker: Mind of a Monster
Director: Alex Emslie
Released: 2020
Duration: 120 min

Representation Score

4.1/10

Fair

2020

TV-14

Director

Alex Emslie

Runtime

120 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

The Butcher Baker: Mind of a Monster operates as a standard true-crime documentary. Its structure is built around the investigation of a singular criminal entity, limiting the scope for storytelling that reflects multiple aspects of identity. Because the film prioritizes the psychological profile of Robert Hansen, the narrative often uses identity—such as gender, race, or mental health—as a backdrop for crime rather than a subject of ability to act. This results in a narrow focus that adheres to conventional genre expectations. Ultimately, the film functions as a character study of a perpetrator. This focus prevents the subversion of social hierarchies or the meaningful representation of underrepresented groups.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does The Butcher Baker: Mind of a Monster have LGBTQ+ representation?

Limited

The film focuses on the perpetrator's psychology rather than exploring LGBTQ+ identity. While the victims were underrepresented, there is no dedicated exploration of LGBTQ+ individuals' ability to act or liberation.

How does The Butcher Baker: Mind of a Monster portray gender?

Fair

The story centers on male characters through the lens of a serial killer. Women are primarily depicted within a criminal framework as victims, failing to challenge traditional gender hierarchies.

How racially and ethnically diverse is The Butcher Baker: Mind of a Monster?

Limited

The Alaskan setting offers cultural potential, but the narrative follows a traditional Western true-crime structure. There is no significant focus on non-Anglo-Saxon perspectives or racial diversity.

How does The Butcher Baker: Mind of a Monster represent religion and culture?

Limited

The documentary prioritizes the criminal narrative over proactive anti-institutional or anti-Western themes. It uses archival footage to reconstruct history without a clear focus on diverse cultural narratives.

Does The Butcher Baker: Mind of a Monster include disability representation?

Minimal

Mental health is treated as a psychological profile to explain violence. There is no portrayal of neurodivergence with ability to act or as a nuanced lived experience.

Present on Screen

Uses a mix of archival footage and actuality to bring historical events to life.
Reconstructs the Alaskan setting effectively through dramatic shooting techniques.

Limited or Absent

Lacks meaningful ability to act for underrepresented groups, focusing instead on the perpetrator's pathology.
Fails to explore the multi-layered identities of victims beyond their roles in a crime.
Uses psychological profiles as narrative tools rather than nuanced representations of mental health.

Official Synopsis

Feature length documentary about the little known serial killer Robert Hansen, who killed for 12 years in the wilderness of Alaska before finally being caught in 1983. A compelling mixture of archive, actuality, interviews and a challenging drama shoot in Alaska brings his story to life.

How are these scores produced? →