
Brotherhood
2020

Representation Score
Good
2010
Not RatedDirector
Manuel Martín Cuenca
Runtime
89 minutes
Average Rating
No ratings yetNew Showbiz Analysis
Half of Oscar is a psychological drama that dismantles social facades rather than emphasizing broad demographic representation. It effectively challenges traditional views of family and masculinity, providing a nuanced look at human connections through complex characters. However, the film remains confined to a homogeneous Mediterranean setting, limiting its scope of cultural plurality. Its strength lies in its sophisticated narrative structure, trading sentimentalism for a realistic portrayal of how secrets and routines shape personal identity.
Category Breakdown
The film does not focus on LGBTQ+ identities but explores a secret that challenges traditional family dynamics and stability.
Maria drives the emotional core and conflict of the story, while Oscar is shown as isolated rather than traditionally strong.
Set in Almeria, the film reflects a homogeneous Mediterranean environment without engaging much with racial or ethnic diversity.
The story questions the sanctity of the nuclear family and traditional morality, using moral relativism to critique established social structures.
The film examines themes of aging and mortality through the dying grandfather, focusing on the existential impact rather than pity.
Present on Screen
Limited or Absent
Official Synopsis
A reunion with his family provides a clue into the cause of one man's lonely life in this drama from filmmaker Manuel Martin Cuenca. Oscar lives in a barren section of Almeria, Spain, where he works as a guard at a salt mine. Oscar's days are governed by a monotonous routine: he goes to work, has lunch with fellow guard Miguel, finishes work, visits his dying grandfather at a hospice, and then goes home. While he sometimes spends his evenings with a woman, it's clear their relationship is not a close one. One day, Oscar gets word that grandfather has been transferred to a hospital, and his sister Maria, who now lives in Paris, comes to Almeria to pay the old man a visit. Maria, who is expecting a baby, is accompanied by her boyfriend Jean , who tries to keep a distance between the two siblings. It becomes clear that Oscar and Maria share an ugly secret that she wants to keep hidden at all costs, leading to an grim tension that grows between her and her brother.

2020

2008

2015

2012

2014

2014

2010

2015
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts on this movie!
Use the rating form above to leave a star rating and optional review.