You are here:

Silence

Name: Silence
Director: Masahiro Shinoda
Released: 1971
Duration: 130 min

Representation Score

4.8/10

Fair

1971

Director

Masahiro Shinoda

Runtime

130 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Masahiro Shinoda’s *Silence* is a profound exploration of Western ideological imposition versus indigenous sovereignty. It avoids the 'civilizing mission' cliché, presenting a sophisticated clash between Portuguese Jesuits and the Japanese state. The film excels in its cultural deconstruction, challenging the perceived supremacy of Western religious institutions. By focusing on the friction of post-colonial encounters, it offers a nuanced view of how foreign dogma disrupts established civilizations. However, the film is limited by its historical setting, resulting in a narrative dominated by male characters and a lack of queer representation. Additionally, while it explores the suffering of the peasantry, it does so as a backdrop rather than a source of character's ability to drive the story.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Silence have LGBTQ+ representation?

Minimal

The film focuses solely on the spiritual and physical struggles of male protagonists. There are no depictions of queer identities or any hints at non-straight relationships.

How does Silence portray gender?

Limited

The narrative is driven by male characters, adhering to 17th-century hierarchies where women play minor roles in the central theological and political conflicts.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Silence?

Good

The film masterfully captures the clash between Portuguese missionaries and the Japanese populace. It portrays the Japanese state as a sophisticated entity defending its cultural integrity.

How does Silence represent religion and culture?

Excellent

Shinoda critiques the imposition of foreign dogma by placing Western religious institutions in conflict with the Tokugawa Shogunate. It favors nuanced, situational ethics over absolute certainty.

Does Silence include disability representation?

Fair

The physical suffering of the peasantry is depicted, serving as a backdrop to theological themes rather than giving characters specific roles or ability to act.

Present on Screen

Sophisticated deconstruction of Western hegemony and religious supremacy.
Nuanced portrayal of the Japanese state defending its cultural integrity.
Effective critique of the imposition of foreign dogma on established civilizations.

Limited or Absent

Lack of representation for non-straight relationships.
Narrative is driven almost entirely by male characters, sidelining women.
Physical suffering is used as a backdrop rather than providing character's ability to drive the story.

Official Synopsis

In 17th-century Japan, two Portuguese Jesuit priests seek their mentor, who is rumoured to have committed apostasy, and to propagate Catholicism.

How are these scores produced? →