You are here:

What Shall We Do with Our Old?

Name: What Shall We Do with Our Old?
Director: D.W. Griffith
Released: 1911
Duration: 14 min

Representation Score

3.3/10

Limited

1911

Director

D.W. Griffith

Runtime

14 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

This early D.W. Griffith drama emphasizes class-based vulnerability and social realism over identity-based representation. The narrative centers on the tension between individual struggles and systemic economic structures, particularly through the lens of ageism and industrial displacement. Although the film lacks diverse representation, including LGBTQ+ identities and racial diversity, it offers a nuanced portrayal of the pressures of early 20th-century capitalism. The protagonist's struggle highlights the conflict between the individual and the industrial machine. Ultimately, the film operates as a period-specific social melodrama. It challenges the idea of meritocratic stability by depicting the elderly worker as a victim of systemic indifference.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does What Shall We Do with Our Old? have LGBTQ+ representation?

Minimal

The film does not include any depictions of LGBTQ+ identities or queer subtext. It stays within traditional domestic and family structures.

How does What Shall We Do with Our Old? portray gender?

Fair

Characters adhere to traditional social roles and gendered domesticity. The film examines emotional labor and interpersonal conflicts within a conventional family setting.

How racially and ethnically diverse is What Shall We Do with Our Old??

Minimal

The cast is uniform, reflecting the production standards of 1911. There is no indication of multicultural casting or narratives featuring non-Anglo-Saxon characters.

How does What Shall We Do with Our Old? represent religion and culture?

Fair

The story critiques early industrial capitalism. It portrays the protagonist's desperation as a result of systemic ageism and economic instability.

Does What Shall We Do with Our Old? include disability representation?

Limited

Illness serves as a plot catalyst rather than an exploration of lived experience. The wife's condition drives the protagonist's socioeconomic crisis.

Present on Screen

Provides an early critique of industrial capitalism and systemic ageism.
Examines the socio-economic pressures and vulnerabilities of the working class.
Highlights the friction between individuals and economic structures through social realism.

Limited or Absent

Does not include any representation of LGBTQ+ identities or queer subtext.
Features a homogeneous cast with no racial or ethnic diversity.
Uses illness as a plot device without exploring the lived experience of disability.

Official Synopsis

An elderly carpenter is told by a doctor that his wife is seriously ill. Soon afterwards, an insensitive shop foreman lays him off from his job because of his age. Unable to find work, and with his wife's condition getting worse, he soon becomes desperate.

How are these scores produced? →