You are here:

By Night with Torch and Spear

Name: By Night with Torch and Spear
Director: Joseph Cornell
Released: 1942
Duration: 8 min

Representation Score

5.4/10

Fair

1942

Director

Joseph Cornell

Runtime

8 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Joseph Cornell’s experimental collage serves as a formalist disruption of traditional cinema. By using a non-narrative format with industrial and ancient imagery, it avoids the character-driven clichés used to measure social identity. The film’s strength lies in its rejection of conventional narrative structures and its embrace of linguistic ambiguity. It challenges viewers to engage with a reality not defined by typical Western norms. While the film does not explicitly address social identities, its abstract nature provides a neutral environment that avoids reinforcing conventional social hierarchies.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does By Night with Torch and Spear have LGBTQ+ representation?

Fair

The film does not depict LGBTQ characters or romantic relationships. Its surreal, non-linear structure avoids reinforcing traditional social norms.

How does By Night with Torch and Spear portray gender?

Fair

The film does not include human characters to establish gender hierarchies. Instead, it focuses on smoke and steam, avoiding traditional gender roles but without actively challenging power dynamics.

How racially and ethnically diverse is By Night with Torch and Spear?

Fair

The collage features a mix of industrial and ancient motifs, suggesting a broad historical scope that goes beyond a single Western viewpoint. However, there is no specific visual evidence of a diverse cast.

How does By Night with Torch and Spear represent religion and culture?

Good

Cornell uses backwards title cards and alien languages to challenge Western communication norms. This approach rejects singular institutional truths in favor of abstract experiences.

Does By Night with Torch and Spear include disability representation?

Minimal

There is no depiction of characters or situations involving disability in this experimental short.

Present on Screen

Avoids reinforcing traditional social norms through its non-linear, surrealist structure.
Uses backwards title cards and alien languages to challenge Western linguistic norms.
Focuses on abstract imagery rather than traditional narrative structures.

Limited or Absent

Does not actively challenge traditional gender power dynamics due to the absence of human characters.
Does not provide explicit affirmation of specific social or racial identities.
Abstract subject matter prevents engagement with specific identity-based narratives.

Official Synopsis

Smoke, sparks and steam dance together in Cornell's found-footage collage. Backwards title cards (or an alien language, if you like) punctuate this mishmash of the industrial and the ancient.

How are these scores produced? →