You are here:

To Be and to Have

Name: To Be and to Have
Director: Nicolas Philibert
Released: 2002
Duration: 104 min

Representation Score

4.8/10

Fair

2002

Not Rated

Director

Nicolas Philibert

Runtime

104 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Nicolas Philibert’s observational approach emphasizes humanistic dignity over fabricated narrative tension. Using a Direct Cinema method, the film captures the authentic lived experience of a mixed-age classroom in rural France. The work does not engage in challenging conventional views or identity politics, resulting in a lack of explicit representation for LGBTQ+ identities or diverse racial backgrounds. Instead, it reflects the specific geographic and historical context of its setting. Ultimately, the film's strength lies in its refusal to 'other' its subjects. It treats the diverse cognitive and emotional needs of the children as a natural part of the human experience.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does To Be and to Have have LGBTQ+ representation?

Minimal

The film focuses on the natural rhythms of a rural French primary school. There are no depictions of LGBTQ+ identities or stories that address the assumption that everyone is straight or cisgender.

How does To Be and to Have portray gender?

Fair

Gender roles are shown through organic social development and spontaneous play. The central power dynamic is based on the relationship between the teacher and his students.

How racially and ethnically diverse is To Be and to Have?

Fair

The cast reflects the demographics of a small, rural community. Although the community appears relatively uniform, the individuals are presented with personal depth and a significant role in driving the story.

How does To Be and to Have represent religion and culture?

Fair

The film presents a secular, humanist view of education and community life. It avoids religious dogma, focusing instead on the social dynamics within the classroom.

Does To Be and to Have include disability representation?

Fair

The documentary captures a range of neurodivergent behaviors and developmental paces. These are integrated into the classroom flow with dignity rather than used as plot devices.

Present on Screen

Provides significant depth to all subjects.
Portrays neurodivergent behaviors with dignity and respect.
Avoids rigid gender stereotypes through spontaneous social interaction.

Limited or Absent

Lacks representation of non-assuming gender matches what was assigned at birth identities or LGBTQ+ stories.
Reflects a relatively homogeneous racial demographic due to its specific setting.
Does not explicitly critique or explore Western institutional structures.

Official Synopsis

The documentary's title translates as "to be and to have", the two auxiliary verbs in the French language. It is about a primary school in the commune of Saint-Étienne-sur-Usson, Puy-de-Dôme, France, the population of which is just over 200. The school has one small class of mixed ages (from four to twelve years), with a dedicated teacher, Georges Lopez, who shows patience and respect for the children as we follow their story through a single school year.

How are these scores produced? →