New Showbiz

You are here:
To Be and to Have

To Be and to Have

2002

Not Rated

Director

Nicolas Philibert

Runtime

104 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

Synopsis

The documentary's title translates as "to be and to have", the two auxiliary verbs in the French language. It is about a primary school in the commune of Saint-Étienne-sur-Usson, Puy-de-Dôme, France, the population of which is just over 200. The school has one small class of mixed ages (from four to twelve years), with a dedicated teacher, Georges Lopez, who shows patience and respect for the children as we follow their story through a single school year.

Where to Watch

Diversity & Representation

Overall Score

5.0/10

Fair


Category Breakdown

LGBTQ+ Representation

Minimal

The film focuses on the naturalistic rhythms of a rural French primary school. There are no depictions of non-cisnormative identities or narratives addressing heteronormativity.

Gender Representation

Fair

Gender is depicted through organic social development and spontaneous play. The central power dynamic rests on the pedagogical relationship between the teacher and his students.

Racial & Ethnic Diversity

Fair

The cast reflects the demographic reality of a small, rural commune. While the community appears relatively homogeneous, the subjects are presented with individual depth and agency.

Religious & Cultural Diversity

Fair

The film presents a secular, humanist view of education and community. It avoids religious dogma, focusing instead on the micro-social dynamics of the classroom.

Disability Representation

Fair

The documentary captures a spectrum of neurodivergent behaviors and developmental paces. These are integrated into the classroom flow with dignity rather than used as plot devices.

Strengths

  • Provides high agency and individual depth to all subjects.
  • Portrays neurodivergent behaviors with significant dignity and respect.
  • Avoids rigid gendered archetypes through spontaneous social interaction.

Areas for Improvement

  • Lacks representation of non-cisnormative identities or LGBTQ+ narratives.
  • Reflects a relatively homogeneous racial demographic due to its specific setting.
  • Does not explicitly critique or explore Western institutional structures.

AI Analysis

Nicolas Philibert’s observational approach prioritizes humanistic dignity over manufactured narrative tension. By utilizing a Direct Cinema methodology, the film captures the authentic lived experience of a mixed-age classroom in rural France. The work does not engage in systemic subversion or identity politics, which results in a lack of explicit representation for LGBTQ+ identities or diverse racial backgrounds. Instead, it mirrors the specific geographic and historical context of its setting. Ultimately, the film's strength lies in its refusal to 'other' its subjects. It treats the diverse cognitive and emotional needs of the children as a natural component of the human experience.

How are these scores produced? →

Similar Movies

Movie poster for La Maison de la Radio

La Maison de la Radio

2013

No user ratings available yet
Diversity score: 4.8 out of 10

Rate this Movie

No rating selected
Use arrow keys to select a rating from 1 to 5 stars
Optional text review, maximum 2000 characters
Tip: Wrap spoilers with ||double pipes|| to hide them
0/2000 characters
You must be signed in to submit a rating

Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts on this movie!

Use the rating form above to leave a star rating and optional review.