You are here:

Tell Spring Not to Come This Year

Name: Tell Spring Not to Come This Year
Director: Michael McEvoy, Saeed Taji Farouky
Released: 2015
Duration: 87 min

Representation Score

4.6/10

Fair

2015

Director

Michael McEvoy, Saeed Taji Farouky

Runtime

87 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

This documentary provides a vital shift in perspective by centering the Afghan National Army during a period of geopolitical transition. By moving away from the Western gaze, it offers a nuanced look at local ability to act and the realities of post-colonial security. However, the film operates within a highly traditional framework regarding gender and identity. The focus on frontline combat units naturally emphasizes a masculine-centric experience, leaving little room for diverse gender or LGBTQ+ narratives. Ultimately, the film's value lies in its ability to deconstruct conventional war clichés. It replaces the 'savior' narrative with a gritty, localized critique of systemic neglect and the complexities of sovereignty.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Tell Spring Not to Come This Year have LGBTQ+ representation?

Fair

The film focuses on military operations and tactical survival in Helmand Province. There is no explicit depiction of LGBTQ+ identities or stories that challenge the assumption that everyone is straight or cisgender.

How does Tell Spring Not to Come This Year portray gender?

Limited

The narrative centers on an ANA company, a traditionally male-dominated institution. The film prioritizes the masculine experience of warfare and systemic neglect over the roles of women or challenges to traditional gender roles.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Tell Spring Not to Come This Year?

Excellent

The documentary excels by centering Afghan soldiers rather than NATO perspectives. This disrupts the 'Western savior' cliché and provides real power to local actors in a geopolitical context.

How does Tell Spring Not to Come This Year represent religion and culture?

Good

The film critiques international intervention by highlighting the scarcity and mistrust left behind. It frames the transition of power through the lens of broader social or institutional failures and instability.

Does Tell Spring Not to Come This Year include disability representation?

Minimal

No specific details regarding physical or neurodivergent disabilities are present. The focus remains on the collective military struggle of the frontline units.

Present on Screen

Disrupts the 'Western savior' cliché by centering local Afghan soldiers.
Provides real power to non-Western actors in a high-stakes setting.
Offers a critical view of international intervention and systemic failures.

Limited or Absent

Lacks representation of women's roles within the military narrative.
Provides no explicit engagement with LGBTQ+ identities or narratives.
Focuses heavily on masculine experiences of warfare.

Official Synopsis

When NATO troops withdrew from Afghanistan, the Afghan National Army (ANA) took over control of Helmand Province, an extremely dangerous region where attacks by Taliban fighters are the order of the day. Security, much less peace, would seem to be unattainable; it is even difficult to find a common language in a country where everyone mistrusts each other. The directors of this film accompanied an ANA company during a year of frontline duty in Helmand. The soldiers are paid irregularly, there are not enough supplies and their equipment is substandard. They cannot fight a war with the equipment left behind by the ISAF.

How are these scores produced? →