You are here:

The Story of a Poor Young Man

Name: The Story of a Poor Young Man
Director: Ettore Scola
Released: 1995
Duration: 111 min

Representation Score

5.4/10

Fair

1995

Director

Ettore Scola

Runtime

111 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Ettore Scola’s drama emphasizes class struggle and moral ambiguity over demographic variety. The film focuses on a bleak character study of social stagnation rather than identity-based representation. The narrative structure is primarily traditional, centered on a male-driven plot and a homogeneous social environment. While it avoids common clichés about 'ideal' femininity, it lacks depth in representing diverse identities. Ultimately, the film's strength lies in its critique of social institutions and the breakdown of the traditional family unit, though it offers little in the way of diverse identity representation.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does The Story of a Poor Young Man have LGBTQ+ representation?

Limited

The film does not include any LGBTQ+ characters or themes. The main conflict revolves around a traditional, troubled heterosexual marriage.

How does The Story of a Poor Young Man portray gender?

Fair

Mrs. Bartoloni challenges typical feminine stereotypes by being portrayed as a disheveled alcoholic. However, the story centers on a male-driven conspiracy, keeping women as passive recipients of male actions.

How racially and ethnically diverse is The Story of a Poor Young Man?

Limited

The story takes place in a localized, homogeneous Italian setting. There is no indication of a multi-ethnic cast or diverse racial backgrounds.

How does The Story of a Poor Young Man represent religion and culture?

Good

The film provides a strong socioeconomic critique. It deconstructs the 'ideal family' by showing domestic life as a source of entrapment and suffering.

Does The Story of a Poor Young Man include disability representation?

Limited

Characters experience psychological distress and existential unhappiness. These issues are framed as socioeconomic conditions rather than specific disabilities.

Present on Screen

Challenges traditional feminine stereotypes through the unidealized portrayal of Mrs. Bartoloni.
Offers a sharp socioeconomic critique of the failure of social institutions.
Explores complex moral ambiguity and the deconstruction of the traditional family unit.

Limited or Absent

Lacks representation of LGBTQ+ identities or non-cisgender themes.
Maintains a patriarchal power dynamic where women are passive recipients of male actions.
Focuses on a homogeneous setting with little racial or ethnic diversity.

Official Synopsis

Two neighbours, young Vincenzo and old Mr Bartoloni, are utterly unhappy. On the one hand, Vincenzo must lead a miserable and frustrating life as he cannot find any regular job, despite his Arts degree. On the other, Mr Bartoloni is fed up with his despotic wife: the woman who used to be a beautiful artist is now a fat and shabby drunkard. The two men meet on a particularly sad night and, during an outburst, Mr. Bartoloni asks Vincenzo to help him to get rid of his wife by simulating an accident with the promise of a reward.

How are these scores produced? →