You are here:

What, No Men?

Name: What, No Men?
Director: Ralph Staub
Released: 1935
Duration: 21 min

Representation Score

2.3/10

Limited

1935

Approved

Director

Ralph Staub

Runtime

21 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

What, No Men? is a 1930s escapist comedy that uses a 'fish out of water' concept. While it slightly disrupts traditional gender roles by showing men in vulnerable situations, it does so in a humorous rather than socially critical manner. The film relies on the era's tendency to use oversimplified and stereotypical images of ethnic groups. By portraying an ethnic group as a backdrop for comedy, it reinforces colonialist views rather than offering diverse and authentic cultural representation. Overall, the film reflects the traditional storytelling methods of its time. It focuses on conventional comedic clichés rather than on sophisticated narrative techniques or genuine cultural engagement.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does What, No Men? have LGBTQ+ representation?

Limited

The film does not include any characters with non-binary gender identities or same-sex relationships. It follows the assumption that everyone is straight and cisgender, which was common in 1930s cinema.

How does What, No Men? portray gender?

Fair

The story challenges traditional male dominance by putting male characters in vulnerable situations. However, the depiction of an all-female tribe seems to serve as a comedic device rather than a deep look at gender issues.

How racially and ethnically diverse is What, No Men??

Limited

Using an Indian tribe as the setting suggests a colonialist viewpoint. These types of depictions in the 1930s often used simplified and stereotypical images of ethnic groups.

How does What, No Men? represent religion and culture?

Limited

The story uses Western-centric humor and adventure stories. There is no indication that it questions or breaks down Western cultural norms.

Does What, No Men? include disability representation?

Minimal

There is no information about how the film portrays characters with physical or cognitive differences.

Present on Screen

It places male characters in vulnerable situations, challenging traditional male dominance.

Limited or Absent

Avoid using oversimplified and stereotypical images of ethnic groups.
Move beyond using gendered societies as mere comedic devices for exoticization.
Include more authentic and nuanced cultural representation instead of relying on Western-centric frameworks.

Official Synopsis

A bill collector and a policeman are captured by a group of mad scientists and taken to an all-female Indian tribe for study.

How are these scores produced? →