You are here:

Why She Smiles

Name: Why She Smiles
Released: 2021

Representation Score

5.8/10

Fair

2021

TV-G

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Why She Smiles succeeds by subverting the typical tragedy-focused documentary cliché. Instead of viewing illness through a lens of medical proceduralism, the film centers the subjective ability to act and psychological fortitude of Jamie Sorum. The documentary excels in its portrayal of disability, avoiding 'inspiration porn' by grounding the narrative in the harsh realities of neurological decay. It treats the protagonist's condition as a central, complex identity rather than a tool for external character growth. While the film provides a powerful look at neurodivergent struggle, the lack of information regarding racial, ethnic, or LGBTQ+ the way different parts of someone's identity overlap limits its overall diversity impact. It remains a focused, singular study of personal resilience.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Why She Smiles have LGBTQ+ representation?

Fair

The film does not include any explicit LGBTQ+ characters or dynamics that challenge the assumption that everyone is straight or cisgender. The narrative focuses on the intersection of individual identity and chronic illness.

How does Why She Smiles portray gender?

Fair

The documentary challenges the cliché of female frailty by centering a protagonist defined by emotional endurance. Sorum plays a significant role in driving the story rather than being framed as a passive sufferer.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Why She Smiles?

Minimal

There is no specific information regarding the racial or ethnic composition of the cast or subject. A score cannot be assigned without risking speculative inaccuracy.

How does Why She Smiles represent religion and culture?

Good

The film prioritizes humanistic morality and personal resilience over clinical or institutional frameworks. It avoids traditional narratives of suffering as penance, focusing instead on individual ability to act.

Does Why She Smiles include disability representation?

Excellent

This is the film's strongest area, treating Huntington's Disease as a complex identity rather than a plot device. It humanizes neurological decay through a lens of dignity and hope.

Present on Screen

Provides a nuanced, dignified portrayal of a rare neurological condition.
Subverts the 'passive sufferer' cliché by emphasizing the protagonist's ability to drive the story.
Avoids clinical pessimism in favor of a humanistic, resilient narrative.

Limited or Absent

Lacks visible representation or information regarding racial and ethnic diversity.
Provides no evidence of LGBTQ+ characters or non-straight-centered relationship dynamics.

Official Synopsis

Why She Smiles is the true, inspirational story of 34-year old Jamie Sorum, who is battling Huntington's Disease. Huntington's Disease is a rare, fatal neurological disease with symptoms being described as having ALS (Lou Gehrig's Disease), Alzheimer's, and Parkinson's all simultaneously. There is no cure. Why She Smiles brings awareness to the necessity of a cure, and highlights Jamie's unfaltering ability to face each day with hope, joy, and surpassing bravery.

How are these scores produced? →