I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco

No LGBTQ+ characters appear in the film. The narrative revolves around a heterosexual marriage and a same-sex affair triangle, but no queer identities are represented or explored.

Mary Jo Buttafuoco is the sole protagonist and narrator, driving the plot through her survival and testimony. The film frames a woman as the central victim of a crime committed by another woman.

The cast list features names suggesting a predominantly white ensemble. No characters of color are identified in the synopsis or credited roles, limiting racial representation.

The narrative focuses on a specific American crime story without explicit political framing. The setting is a suburban Long Island home, reflecting a traditional domestic context.

No characters with physical or mental disabilities are shown or identified. The shooting incident is treated as a violent crime rather than a disability narrative.