You are here:

Dilemma

Name: Dilemma
Director: Alan Smithee, Eric Louzil
Released: 1997
Duration: 83 min

Representation Score

5.0/10

Fair

1997

Director

Alan Smithee, Eric Louzil

Runtime

83 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Dilemma follows a typical 1990s action-thriller trajectory, emphasizing high-stakes pursuit and medical drama over social critique. The narrative relies heavily on established genre formulas, such as the heroic detective and the criminal redemption arc. The film's approach to diversity is mostly superficial. While it introduces racial tension through its central conflict, it lacks depth in its portrayal of gender and disability, often using these elements as mere plot devices or decorative accessories. Additionally, the use of the 'Alan Smithee' pseudonym suggests a lack of cohesive creative vision, which may explain the film's adherence to safe, conventional storytelling patterns rather than any intentional progressive themes.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Dilemma have LGBTQ+ representation?

Limited

The film does not include any visible engagement with LGBTQ themes or non-straight identities. The main conflict revolves around law enforcement and medical issues.

How does Dilemma portray gender?

Fair

Female characters seem to be portrayed through the male perspective, particularly Lydia, who is described as a 'sexy partner.' This indicates a reliance on conventional stereotypes rather than intellectual empowerment.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Dilemma?

Fair

Racial diversity is introduced through Rudy Salazar, a character of color. The storyline explores tensions between a criminal and law enforcement, though it leans towards familiar clichés.

How does Dilemma represent religion and culture?

Limited

The narrative follows a traditional Western framework of justice, reinforcing state authority and a standard good-versus-evil dichotomy without delving into alternative cultural viewpoints.

Does Dilemma include disability representation?

Fair

Leukemia serves as a primary plot device to heighten the narrative stakes. The illness functions more as a catalyst for tension than a detailed exploration of physical disability.

Present on Screen

Introduces racial complexity through the interaction between a character of color and law enforcement.
Uses a high-stakes medical dilemma to create immediate narrative tension and moral stakes.

Limited or Absent

Avoid framing female characters through the male perspective or as mere sexualized support for male leads.
Move beyond using illness as a simple plot device to provide more nuanced disability representation.
Incorporate more diverse cultural perspectives beyond traditional Western legal and moral frameworks.

Official Synopsis

Whichever side he chooses, someone's gonna die. Death row inmate Rudy Salazar cuts a deal he can't refuse: he'll donate his rare bone marrow to a young girl dying of leukemia. In return, his death sentence is commuted to life without parole. L.A. Detective Quin (C. Thomas Howell), the cop who brought Salazar's murderous rampage to an end, sees through Salazar's selfless facade. En route to the hospital, Salazar makes a daring escape. Now it's up to Quin and his sexy partner, Lydia, to bring Salazar to justice one more time and save the life of an innocent little girl before it's too late.

How are these scores produced? →