You are here:

Promises

Name: Promises
Director: Carlos Bolado, Justine Shapiro, B. Z. Goldberg
Released: 2001
Duration: 106 min

Representation Score

5.4/10

Fair

2001

Director

Carlos Bolado, Justine Shapiro, B. Z. Goldberg

Runtime

106 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Promises succeeds by dismantling monolithic cultural portrayals, replacing them with a fragmented view of identity and ability to act. By centering the lived experiences of underrepresented youth, the film effectively challenges the 'us vs. them' binary through individual testimonies. The documentary's strength lies in its refusal to use authoritative narration, instead prioritizing the voices of its subjects. This approach allows for a sophisticated critique of systemic power dynamics and the impact of religious extremism on vulnerable populations. However, the film's narrow focus on geopolitical and religious identities results in a lack of representation for LGBTQ+ and disability themes. While these absences reflect the specific cultural context, they limit the film's overall inclusivity.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Promises have LGBTQ+ representation?

Minimal

The film focuses on geopolitical and religious identities. There is no discernible focus on non-traditional gender identities or LGBTQ+ narratives.

How does Promises portray gender?

Fair

The documentary provides a balanced platform for both male and female subjects. Young girls have equal opportunities to share their perspectives on conflict and security.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Promises?

Excellent

The narrative centers on the intersection of Jewish Israeli and Palestinian Arab identities. It avoids treating these groups as monoliths through nuanced, individual stories.

How does Promises represent religion and culture?

Excellent

The film examines how historical trauma and geographic realities shape subjective truths. It critiques systemic failures like nationalism and religious extremism through a post-colonial lens.

Does Promises include disability representation?

Minimal

The film documents the psychological toll of conflict but lacks central depictions of physical or neurodivergent disabilities.

Present on Screen

Avoids treating Jewish Israeli and Palestinian Arab identities as monoliths.
Grants female subjects equal opportunities to share their perspectives.
Prioritizes subject voices by avoiding traditional 'voice of God' narration.
Examines the impact of systemic power dynamics on vulnerable youth.

Limited or Absent

Lacks focus on non-traditional gender identities or LGBTQ+ narratives.
Does not provide central depictions of physical or neurodivergent disabilities.

Official Synopsis

Documentarians Justine Shapiro and B.Z. Goldberg traveled to Israel to interview Palestinian and Israeli kids ages 11 to 13, assembling their views on living in a society afflicted with violence, separatism and religious and political extremism. This 2002 Oscar nominee for Best Feature Documentary culminates in an astonishing day in which two Israeli children meet Palestinian youngsters at a refugee camp.

How are these scores produced? →