You are here:

Promises

Name: Promises
Director: Kim Ki-young
Released: 1975
Duration: 95 min

Representation Score

8.5/10

Excellent

1975

Director

Kim Ki-young

Runtime

95 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Kim Ki-young’s *Promises* is a psychological exploration that challenges traditional hierarchies. The film stands out in its gender representation, replacing the passive female archetype with a protagonist who drives the narrative through extreme ability to act and violence. While the film offers a culturally authentic South Korean perspective, it lacks depth in its portrayal of mental health issues and does not delve into explicit queer identities. Psychological states are primarily used to fuel the plot's tension rather than to provide meaningful character studies. Ultimately, the film is a study of moral relativism. It uses its characters and unconventional settings to challenge the social norms and patriarchal structures of its time.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Promises have LGBTQ+ representation?

Fair

The film includes a butch female prison guard who challenges traditional feminine roles. However, the film does not explore her queer identity or any romantic relationships, which limits the score.

How does Promises portray gender?

Excellent

Sook-young breaks away from the passive female stereotype by becoming a central driver of chaos and violence. Women in the film frequently take control, showing significant psychological and physical influence.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Promises?

Good

Set in 1970s South Korea, the film presents a genuine local perspective. It avoids a Western-centric viewpoint by focusing on its own cultural and social context.

How does Promises represent religion and culture?

Good

The story deconstructs traditional institutions using symbols such as a bizarre graveyard wedding. It explores situational ethics and class tensions rather than adhering to a single, traditional moral compass.

Does Promises include disability representation?

Limited

Psychological instability and obsession drive the thriller elements of the plot. However, these mental states serve mainly as narrative devices for tension rather than as nuanced explorations of neurodivergence.

Present on Screen

Positions women as central, powerful drivers of chaos, breaking traditional gender roles.
Presents an authentic South Korean cultural perspective without a Western-centric lens.
Uses unconventional character archetypes like the butch guard to challenge norms.

Limited or Absent

Uses psychological instability primarily as a plot device rather than a nuanced character study.
Does not include explicit queer identity or romantic relationships to deepen subversion.
Relies on thriller clichés when depicting mental health and obsessive behaviors.

Official Synopsis

Mild-mannered and modest Sook-young looks like your usual middle-aged woman, but happens to be a man-killing murderess. On a train trip to Mokpo, she remembers an earlier trip as a prisoner on furlough accompanied by a menacing but kind butch female guard. On the train they meet Hoon, a young man who falls for Sook-young. The guard lets them be alone at a bizarre marriage in a hill-top graveyard.

How are these scores produced? →