You are here:

One Stays, the Other Leaves

Name: One Stays, the Other Leaves
Director: Claude Berri
Released: 2005
Duration: 109 min

Representation Score

2.9/10

Limited

2005

Director

Claude Berri

Runtime

109 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Claude Berri’s drama examines the instability of personal relationships and the breakdown of traditional family life. While it questions the idea of permanent marriages through themes of infidelity, the film stays within a conventional framework. The narrative lacks deep exploration of multiple identities or diverse backgrounds. Instead, it focuses on the weaknesses of a specific social class. Ultimately, the film looks through a narrow lens, missing chances to represent underrepresented identities or challenge Eurocentric norms.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does One Stays, the Other Leaves have LGBTQ+ representation?

Limited

The film focuses on cheating and changing traditional family structures but does not include any queer stories or characters with diverse gender identities.

How does One Stays, the Other Leaves portray gender?

Fair

The story revolves around husbands having affairs, often putting women in passive roles. However, the tension about who stays or leaves hints at questioning the marriage contract.

How racially and ethnically diverse is One Stays, the Other Leaves?

Limited

The film depicts a society with few diverse faces, typical of mid-2000s European dramas. It does not show a mix of ethnic backgrounds or identities.

How does One Stays, the Other Leaves represent religion and culture?

Fair

Marriage is shown as a fragile arrangement rather than a sacred bond. The film explores moral flexibility around fidelity but does not directly criticize institutions.

Does One Stays, the Other Leaves include disability representation?

Minimal

There are no characters with visible or hidden disabilities. The film does not address neurodivergence or physical impairments.

Present on Screen

Questions the stability of traditional Western family models.
Explores the complexities of human weakness and relationship turmoil.
Examines the marriage contract through the lens of personal desires.

Limited or Absent

Does not deeply explore multiple identities or underrepresented groups.
Maintains a homogeneous social setting typical of upper-class dramas.
Does not include queer stories or characters with diverse gender identities.

Official Synopsis

A story about two couples, longtime friends in which both husbands engage in long-term affairs and, as the title says, ultimately one remains with his wife and one makes a new life with another woman.

How are these scores produced? →