You are here:

12 Years of DFA: Too Old To Be New, Too New To Be Classic

Name: 12 Years of DFA: Too Old To Be New, Too New To Be Classic
Director: Max Joseph
Released: 2013
Duration: 14 min

Representation Score

4.4/10

Fair

2013

Director

Max Joseph

Runtime

14 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

This documentary serves as a specialized cultural archive for the NYC indie-dance movement. It succeeds in documenting a non-conformist, multicultural artistic ecosystem that rejects mainstream capitalist music structures. However, the film's primary objective is historical and musical rather than an exploration of multi-layered identity. The narrative architecture remains centered on the technical evolution of the DFA label, which results in a lack of explicit representation for underrepresented groups. While the film captures the spirit of a diverse subculture, it lacks the structured storytelling required to highlight specific queer, female, or disabled narratives.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does 12 Years of DFA: Too Old To Be New, Too New To Be Classic have LGBTQ+ representation?

Fair

The film captures the social fabric of the NYC dance community, which historically includes significant queer presence. However, it lacks explicit, centralized LGBTQ+ storytelling or specific queer character arcs.

How does 12 Years of DFA: Too Old To Be New, Too New To Be Classic portray gender?

Fair

The narrative focuses on the technical and creative output of the DFA label. Representation leans toward male-dominated leadership roles and traditional industry norms without clear evidence of female-led ability to act.

How racially and ethnically diverse is 12 Years of DFA: Too Old To Be New, Too New To Be Classic?

Fair

The documentary explores a multicultural artistic ecosystem within New York City. The inclusion of artists like Sinkane suggests a narrative that extends beyond standard Anglo-Saxon indie clichés.

How does 12 Years of DFA: Too Old To Be New, Too New To Be Classic represent religion and culture?

Good

The film celebrates a DIY ethos and artistic autonomy over mainstream commercial structures. It prioritizes niche, community-driven expressions and the unique identity of the indie music scene.

Does 12 Years of DFA: Too Old To Be New, Too New To Be Classic include disability representation?

Minimal

There is no discernible information regarding the portrayal of individuals with physical or neurodivergent disabilities within the film.

Present on Screen

Celebrates a multicultural artistic ecosystem through the inclusion of diverse artists like Sinkane.
Highlights a DIY, independent ethos that challenges mainstream commercial music hierarchies.
Captures the non-conformist spirit of the NYC indie-dance subculture.

Limited or Absent

Lacks explicit, centralized storytelling for LGBTQ+ individuals and queer narratives.
Features a male-dominated focus on technical and leadership roles within the music industry.
Provides no discernible representation or information regarding disability.

Official Synopsis

In the latest film from Red Bull Music Academy, we turn our attention to DFA: the iconic NYC record label that got the indie kids to dance. Narrated by Marc Maron, it features music and appearances from James Murphy, LCD Soundsystem, The Rapture, Holy Ghost!, The Juan MacLean, Shit Robot, Sinkane, YACHT and many more! - Written by Anonymous

How are these scores produced? →