
Murder, Take One
2005

2019
Director
Ali Atay
Runtime
112 minutes
Average Rating
No ratings yetSynopsis
Istanbul Police Department homicide detectives encounter a murder nothing like they’ve seen before.Commissioners Emin, Salih, Asuman and deputy Alaattin begin investigating.But strange murders keep happening. They don’t have any evidence or any clues. Day by day, tempers flare and the police chiefs grow annoyed.As the murders keep piling up, the public’s interest rises. The pressure on Emin and his colleagues get intense. At last, the chief of police assigns “crime expert” Dizdar Koşu, who has recently come back from the US, to the team.Overwhelmed with panic, pressure and disdain, Emin and his friends try to solve the strangest series of murders with the most unusual methods.This fast race against time immediately turns into a tragicomedy.
Overall Score
Fair
Category Breakdown
LGBTQ+ Representation
The film focuses on professional friction within a male-dominated police unit. It lacks explicit character arcs centered on non-cisnormative identities, remaining within traditional social frameworks.
Gender Representation
Asuman provides a necessary professional counterpoint to the male detectives. However, the comedic engine relies heavily on the chaotic and inept behavior of the male protagonists.
Racial & Ethnic Diversity
The story depicts a demographic consistent with its Istanbul setting. It does not explore intersectional racial dynamics, focusing instead on local social realism.
Religious & Cultural Diversity
The film excels at critiquing institutional stability. It uses tragicomedy to highlight the absurdity and dysfunction of state institutions when faced with unpredictable crises.
Disability Representation
There is no significant presence of neurodivergent characters or visible disabilities. Character struggles are primarily psychological, driven by stress and professional inadequacy.
Strengths
Areas for Improvement
AI Analysis
Ali Atay’s film functions as a genre-bending critique of institutional efficacy. It subverts the trope of the competent authority figure, replacing it with a fallible and chaotic portrayal of law enforcement. While the film lacks demographic breadth, it finds its voice through social satire. The narrative deconstructs authority by framing the police department as a site of systemic panic and incompetence. Ultimately, the work prioritizes a skeptical view of power structures over diverse representation, using the absurdity of the detectives' methods to highlight institutional fragility.

2005

1977

1994

2004

2010

1971

2012

2017

2000

2018

2004

2013
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts on this movie!
Use the rating form above to leave a star rating and optional review.