You are here:

Unterm Birnbaum

Name: Unterm Birnbaum
Director: Uli Edel
Released: 2019
Duration: 89 min

Representation Score

5.9/10

Fair

2019

Director

Uli Edel

Runtime

89 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Unterm Birnbaum excels as a character study that challenges mid-20th-century social norms. Its primary strength lies in the sophisticated portrayal of gender performance and women's ability to drive the story, positioning Dietrich as a figure who navigates and defies patriarchal hierarchies. However, the film's scope is inherently narrow due to its biographical nature. The focus on a specific European historical context limits racial and ethnic diversity, keeping the narrative centered on a predominantly white, German-born experience. Ultimately, the film is a study of individual conviction against systemic oppression. It prioritizes a deep, nuanced exploration of how one person challenges the restrictive structures of both totalitarian states and the studio system over broad demographic representation.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Unterm Birnbaum have LGBTQ+ representation?

Good

The film examines gender performance through Marlene Dietrich’s public persona. Her use of masculine clothing and non-traditional gender expression challenges the assumption that everyone is straight or cisgender.

How does Unterm Birnbaum portray gender?

Excellent

The story focuses on a female lead who plays a significant role in driving the plot. Dietrich frequently defies patriarchal expectations within both German society and the Hollywood industry.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Unterm Birnbaum?

Limited

Diversity is limited by the biographical focus on a specific European historical figure. While it depicts the oppressive environment of Nazi Germany, the cast remains centered on the German-born protagonist.

How does Unterm Birnbaum represent religion and culture?

Good

The film criticizes a centralized, oppressive state by highlighting Dietrich’s personal convictions against traditional nationalistic identities. It emphasizes individual conscience over state-driven ideologies.

Does Unterm Birnbaum include disability representation?

Minimal

There is no significant depiction of visible or invisible disabilities in the narrative.

Present on Screen

Strong portrayal of women's ability to drive the story and intellectual autonomy.
Nuanced exploration of gender performance and non-traditional gender expression.
Effective critique of institutional corruption and oppressive state structures.

Limited or Absent

Limited racial and ethnic diversity due to the specific biographical focus.
Lack of representation regarding visible or invisible disabilities.

Official Synopsis

After the death of their child, the Hradschek couple consoled themselves with gambling and shopping orgies. After the creditor increases the pressure on them, Ursel and Abel decide to kill him.

How are these scores produced? →