You are here:

Return

Name: Return
Director: Haqi Ali
Released: 2015
Duration: 45 min

Representation Score

5.6/10

Fair

2015

Not Rated

Director

Haqi Ali

Runtime

45 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

The film primarily functions as a psychological character study. It successfully centers a neurodivergent protagonist and offers a nuanced critique of how religious and medical institutions shape a person's reality. However, the film lacks depth in representing diverse identities such as race, ethnicity, or LGBTQ+. The narrative remains anchored in a conventional Western framework. While the exploration of schizophrenia provides a platform for disability representation, the film's genre as a 'tale of terror' suggests a potential reliance on mental health clichés for suspense.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Return have LGBTQ+ representation?

Fair

The film does not include any explicit LGBTQ+ characters or stories about non-cisgender identities. The plot focuses solely on the protagonist's psychological and spiritual journey.

How does Return portray gender?

Fair

Cathy Reed is a central female protagonist who navigates worlds shaped by religious and medical institutions. She is portrayed as the main driver of her own reality.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Return?

Minimal

There is no indication of a diverse cast or non-Anglo-Saxon characters. The story is centered around a character named Cathy Reed, reflecting a Western-centric perspective.

How does Return represent religion and culture?

Good

The film contrasts religious exorcism with medical science, creating a tension between spiritual beliefs and secular authority. This critique highlights the conflict between traditional religion and modern medicine.

Does Return include disability representation?

Good

The story revolves around a character dealing with schizophrenia. It explores her journey towards independence, but there is a risk that mental illness is used as a horror cliché.

Present on Screen

Focuses on a neurodivergent protagonist navigating independence.
Highlights the tension between religious dogma and medical science.
Questions traditional gendered expectations of sanity and stability.

Limited or Absent

Could benefit from more diverse racial, ethnic, or LGBTQ+ representation.
Risk of using mental health conditions as mere horror clichés.
Maintains a narrow, Western-centric narrative framework.

Official Synopsis

A tale of terror. Cathy Reed has been institutionalized most of her life because of Schizophrenia, as a child her parents thought she was possessed by demons and had her exercised by priests. Medical science saw different. Now decades later Cathy is freed, relocated to her own flat and given a chance to be independent. Once alone things are not what they all seem and when her nightmares turn real she questions her state of mind before she is left to face her demons.

How are these scores produced? →