
Living and Other Fictions
2016

2024
Director
Catrinel Marlon
Runtime
97 minutes
Average Rating
No ratings yetSynopsis
1963. The young nurse Anna begins working in the juvenile ward of a mental hospital. There she meets Lucia, a fifteen-year-old schizophrenic. Against the backdrop of a struggle between Dr. Marie and the rigid Dr. Oreste to reform patient treatment, a relationship between Anna and Lucia develops, forcing them to make decisive choices for their respective lives.
Overall Score
Good
Category Breakdown
LGBTQ+ Representation
The film explores a developing relationship between a nurse and a teenage patient in 1963. While the romantic nature is not explicitly defined, the narrative hints at intimacy outside conventional heteronormative structures.
Gender Representation
Women drive the central plot through an ideological struggle between Dr. Marie and Dr. Oreste. This positioning challenges mid-century archetypes by granting female characters agency in professional and intellectual spheres.
Racial & Ethnic Diversity
The provided information does not specify the racial or ethnic composition of the cast or setting. As a result, no assessment of racial diversity can be made.
Religious & Cultural Diversity
The story critiques rigid Western medical and psychiatric institutions of the 1960s. It favors a humanistic perspective over singular, authoritative moral frameworks regarding patient treatment.
Disability Representation
The narrative centers on the lived experience of schizophrenia through the character Lucia. It explores complex power dynamics in psychiatric care rather than relying on reductive tropes.
Strengths
Areas for Improvement
AI Analysis
Girasoli succeeds in centering its narrative on characters navigating neurodivergence and institutional reform. By focusing on the agency of both the caregiver and the patient, the film avoids common tropes associated with mental health representation. The film also subverts mid-century gender norms by placing women at the heart of a professional and ideological conflict. This shift from passivity to active institutional critique provides a strong foundation for character-driven drama. However, the film's lack of explicit detail regarding LGBTQ+ identities and racial composition leaves certain dimensions of its social landscape unexamined. The focus remains primarily on the intersection of gender and mental health within a specific historical framework.

2016

1999

2021

2016

2008

2021

2018

2017

2021

1992

1977

2023
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts on this movie!
Use the rating form above to leave a star rating and optional review.