You are here:

Simshar

Name: Simshar
Director: Rebecca Cremona
Released: 2014
Duration: 105 min

Representation Score

7.3/10

Good

2014

TV-14

Director

Rebecca Cremona

Runtime

105 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Simshar is a sophisticated critique of migration politics and the weaknesses of state institutions. Its strength lies in portraying underrepresented groups, such as migrants and stranded sailors, as central to the film's emotional core. The film excels by presenting a multicultural landscape that avoids a homogeneous white norm, giving high ability to act to characters of color. This offers a realistic view of the Mediterranean's complex social fabric. However, the film's impact is limited by a lack of LGBTQ+ representation and a narrow approach to disability, which are largely absent.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Simshar have LGBTQ+ representation?

Minimal

The film does not include explicit LGBTQ+ characters or identities that don't follow traditional gender norms. The story focuses on survival and the conflict in Libya.

How does Simshar portray gender?

Fair

Female characters play important roles and show professional competence. Alex, a medic, contributes intellectually and emotionally, avoiding the stereotype of the passive woman.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Simshar?

Excellent

The film showcases a diverse Mediterranean setting with characters from various backgrounds, including African migrants, Maltese fishermen, and Turkish crews. Characters of color are central to the story.

How does Simshar represent religion and culture?

Good

The story criticizes Western institutions and the bureaucratic conflicts between countries during the migrant crisis. It highlights how administrative processes prioritize political interests over human lives.

Does Simshar include disability representation?

Limited

Physical injuries and mental stress drive the plot in the survival genre. The film does not explore neurodiversity or permanent disabilities.

Present on Screen

Characters of color have significant roles in the migrant crisis narrative.
Competent female characters challenge traditional gender hierarchies.
Critique of systemic failures and Western bureaucratic indifference.

Limited or Absent

No explicit LGBTQ+ representation or identities outside traditional norms.
Limited exploration of disability beyond using physical injury as a plot device.
Little engagement with challenging traditional gender norms.

Official Synopsis

Young Theo is sent on his first trip with his Maltese sea faring family, but things go terribly wrong when the 'Simshar' sinks, leaving the crew stranded in the Mediterranean... Simultaneously, Alex - a medic reluctantly dispatched onto a Turkish Merchant vessel which has rescued a group of stranded African boat people between Malta and Italy - gets stuck on the boat as the countries wage a bureaucratic war over who should take in the migrants... The stories unravel in parallel and culminate tragically when the fishermen are traced down, but by that time there's only one survivor.

How are these scores produced? →