You are here:

As Luck Would Have It

Name: As Luck Would Have It
Director: Lorenzo Gabriele
Released: 2002
Duration: 90 min

Representation Score

5.4/10

Fair

2002

Not Rated

Director

Lorenzo Gabriele

Runtime

90 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

As Luck Would Have It distinguishes itself by placing a same-sex romantic dynamic at the heart of a domestic comedy. By making queer identity a driver of character conflict, the film avoids the common pitfall of treating such identities as mere punchlines. The film also succeeds in deconstructing the traditional Western family unit. Through the lens of Swiss law and unexpected guardianship, it explores situational ethics and the instability of conventional social roles. However, the film remains limited by a lack of racial and disability-based representation. The narrative appears to lean toward a more homogeneous social environment typical of its European setting.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does As Luck Would Have It have LGBTQ+ representation?

Good

The film centers on Jean-Pierre, a protagonist navigating a relationship with his boyfriend. This queer dynamic is a primary source of character conflict rather than a peripheral joke.

How does As Luck Would Have It portray gender?

Fair

The narrative explores the disruption of traditional domestic hierarchies. Jean-Pierre's struggle to balance professional growth with caretaking roles challenges rigid masculine archetypes of the provider.

How racially and ethnically diverse is As Luck Would Have It?

Fair

The story focuses on European social structures within a Swiss setting. There is no evidence of a non-white majority cast or intentional racial diversity in the narrative.

How does As Luck Would Have It represent religion and culture?

Good

The film critiques the rigidity of state-mandated social structures and traditional Western institutions. It challenges the idealized family model by presenting a non-traditional household.

Does As Luck Would Have It include disability representation?

Minimal

No visible or invisible disabilities are portrayed as central to the character arcs or the progression of the plot.

Present on Screen

Integrates queer identity as a meaningful, central element of the domestic plot.
Challenges traditional masculine archetypes through the protagonist's caretaking responsibilities.
Critiques rigid state-mandated social structures and traditional family models.

Limited or Absent

Lacks significant racial and ethnic diversity within the social environment.
Provides no representation of characters with visible or invisible disabilities.

Official Synopsis

Jean-Pierre is a literature professor in Switzerland. Due to the vagarities of Swiss law, he is selected, basically at random, to be the guardian of a parentless teenage boy named Antoine. Conflict comes into the story as Jean-Pierre, who has just accepted a major promotion, must now deal with caring for a teenage boy he doesn't want to care for, as well as handling his own jealous boyfriend. Then his wife steps into the picture. Things get complicated from there as Jean-Pierre tries to get out of his guardianship.

How are these scores produced? →