You are here:

She Said, He Said

Name: She Said, He Said
Director: Claudia Castro
Released: 2019
Duration: 78 min

Representation Score

4.9/10

Fair

2019

Director

Claudia Castro

Runtime

78 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

She Said, He Said is a conventional contemporary teen dramedy that relies heavily on established genre clichés. While it avoids systemic critiques found in more progressive cinema, it stands out by offering a culturally diverse perspective through its Brazilian setting. The film’s strength lies in its character dynamics, especially in how it highlights Rosa’s intellectual discipline as a stabilizing force. This provides a subtle shift from traditional gender roles where the male lead typically drives the plot. However, the narrative prioritizes a heterosexual romantic framework and conventional social hierarchies, limiting its ability to disrupt standard teen romance structures.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does She Said, He Said have LGBTQ+ representation?

Fair

The film features a traditional romantic tension between Rosa and Leo, without any explicit queer-coded subtext or representation of non-cisgender identities.

How does She Said, He Said portray gender?

Fair

Rosa challenges traditional gender roles by emphasizing her intellectual discipline, providing a subtle subversion of female archetypes. However, the presence of a popular girl antagonist indicates adherence to conventional social hierarchies.

How racially and ethnically diverse is She Said, He Said?

Fair

As a Brazilian production, the film showcases a multi-ethnic adolescent landscape typical of contemporary Brazilian society, moving away from Western-centric casting norms.

How does She Said, He Said represent religion and culture?

Fair

The story focuses on the secular, individualistic experience of growing up, exploring the tension between personal identity and family expectations through a modern lens.

Does She Said, He Said include disability representation?

Minimal

The narrative does not include any characters dealing with physical, neurodivergent, or mental health conditions.

Present on Screen

The film highlights Rosa's intellectual discipline, challenging traditional gender roles.
Its Brazilian production provides a naturalistic departure from Western-centric casting norms.
The narrative explores the relatable tension between individual identity and family expectations.

Limited or Absent

The story relies on heterosexual romantic structures and lacks queer representation.
The plot adheres to conventional social hierarchies and genre clichés rather than disrupting them.
There is a lack of representation regarding disabilities or neurodivergent experiences.

Official Synopsis

Rosa (Duda Matte) is dedicated to study, Leo (Marcus Bessa) is a good soccer player. She is always on time, he is always late. She hates Julia (Maisa), the most popular girl in high school, he kind of likes her. They are both new students at school and, besides having to learn how to deal with new friends and family problems, they find out that they have much more in common than they thought. Based on the successful book by Thalita Rebouças, they will find that growing up may seem complicated but deep down it's a great adventure.

How are these scores produced? →