In a Perfect World
2015

Representation Score
Limited
2022
Director
Justine Martin
Runtime
12 minutes
Average Rating
No ratings yetNew Showbiz Analysis
Oasis opens on the quiet intimacy of two brothers sharing a hat, a gesture that immediately establishes the film’s argument: the bond between Raphaël and Rémi is the lens through which all other realities are filtered. The documentary captures a summer suspended in time, where the impending separation into different schools is treated not as a crisis, but as a gentle, inevitable shift in the landscape. The camera lingers on their shared activities—pedal boats, card games, and simple conversations—selling a vision of disability that is deeply humanized and stripped of melodrama. The film’s moral verdict rests on the brothers’ mutual affection and the quiet dignity of Raphaël’s existence. By refusing to frame his condition as a tragedy to be overcome, the director allows the audience to witness a life lived on its own terms. The ending, marked by a simple "good night," affirms the strength of their connection without demanding a resolution to the institutional challenges they face. It is a restrained, honest portrait that trusts the audience to find meaning in the ordinary, leaving the viewer with a sense of warmth rather than pity.
Category Breakdown
The narrative focuses exclusively on the fraternal bond between the twin brothers. No depiction of romantic or sexual identity appears on screen.
The film centers two male subjects, but gender dynamics remain backgrounded in favor of the sibling relationship. No traditional gender roles are actively challenged or reinforced.
The cast consists of the two white twin brothers. No other ethnic or racial perspectives are presented on screen.
The film treats the impending separation from the specialized school system as a neutral life transition. Family bonds are depicted as the primary cultural value, resisting institutional fragmentation.
Raphaël’s disability is portrayed as an unremarkable part of his daily life rather than a tragedy. The narrative emphasizes his autonomy and the brother’s acceptance, avoiding pity or inspiration tropes.
Present on Screen
Limited or Absent
Official Synopsis
As they enter their teenage years, twin brothers Raphaël and Rémi see their fraternal relationship crumble as one of them, suffering from an increasingly marked disability, remains a prisoner of childhood. But for one last summer, as they contemplate nature, time seems to stop momentarily.
2015

2022

2015

2022

2021

2018

2022

2014
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts on this movie!
Use the rating form above to leave a star rating and optional review.