
Faking a Murderer
2020

Representation Score
Fair
2012
Director
Ryan Mitchelle
Runtime
124 minutes
Average Rating
No ratings yetNew Showbiz Analysis
The Cinema Snob Movie opens with a title card mimicking high-end art-house aesthetics, immediately selling intellectual superiority as the film’s core currency. Directed by Ryan Mitchelle, this 2012 indie horror-comedy follows an exploitation filmmaker who goes undercover as a pretentious snob to secure filming permits, thrusting him into a mystery surrounding a secretive film commission. The film’s argument is straightforward: cultural capital is a moral virtue, and the snob’s rigid adherence to "good taste" is the correct way to navigate the world. The pictures consistently favor the snob. Brad Jones’s character, Craig, is the unmarked center of the moral universe, treated with beauty lighting and admiring camera angles. His pretentiousness is charming and correct, while those mocked for their lack of cultural knowledge are never given the same visual respect. The running gag is the "dumb" moviegoer, whose social exclusion is treated as slapstick. No one is mourned for their lack of taste, and Craig never pays a price for his arrogance. He keeps his rank, his status, and the last word in every argument. The ending rewards the character who most rigidly adheres to the hierarchy of taste, punishing those perceived as mainstream. The film prints the legend that "good taste" is an objective moral virtue separating the enlightened from the base. The camera loves the snob, and the audience is asked to emulate him. There is no contradiction between the film’s argument and its internal logic; it fully endorses the snobbery it depicts. The last image settles the moral verdict: the snob wins, and the ordinary person is the joke.
Category Breakdown
No queer characters or intimacy appear. The social hierarchy relies entirely on straight-coded dynamics. The cast and plot contain no identity markers.
Jillian Zurawski plays Nancy Phillips, a female lead who validates the male protagonist’s worldview. Men hold the primary critical voice and authority. Women function as supportive foils.
The cast is entirely white, with no non-white characters depicted. Whiteness is the unmarked default, reinforcing a homogeneous cultural space.
The film treats cultural elitism and "good taste" as moral virtues. The snob’s pretentiousness is rewarded, positioning intellectual superiority as the correct social order.
No disabled characters or impairments are depicted. The narrative focuses on social status and taste rather than physical or cognitive differences.
Present on Screen
Limited or Absent
Official Synopsis
When an exploitation filmmaker goes undercover as a pretentious film snob to obtain proper filming permits, he is thrust into a strange mystery surrounding the very secretive film commission.

2020

2000

2014

2015

2012

2021

2014

2006
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts on this movie!
Use the rating form above to leave a star rating and optional review.