You are here:

First, Second & Third Love

Name: First, Second & Third Love
Director: Gina S. Noer
Released: 2022
Duration: 111 min

Representation Score

5.1/10

Fair

2022

TV-14

Director

Gina S. Noer

Runtime

111 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

First, Second & Third Love moves away from typical romantic clichés by emphasizing the emotional weight of caregiving and interpersonal secrets. The film prioritizes character-driven storytelling and emotional authenticity over simplified archetypes. However, the film lacks clear markers of multi-layered subversion. There is no obvious evidence of LGBTQ+ themes or critiques of social institutions, keeping the narrative within more traditional romantic boundaries. Ultimately, the film succeeds in offering a culturally grounded Indonesian perspective. It opts for a nuanced, realistic portrayal of the complexities of human connection and domestic responsibility over idealized perfection.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does First, Second & Third Love have LGBTQ+ representation?

Fair

The story focuses on the romance between Asia and Raja. There is no clear indication of characters with non-traditional gender identities or narratives that challenge the assumption that everyone is straight or cisgender.

How does First, Second & Third Love portray gender?

Fair

The emphasis on characters caring for parents highlights a potential shift from traditional gender roles towards a more emotionally driven dynamic.

How racially and ethnically diverse is First, Second & Third Love?

Good

As an Indonesian production, the film showcases the local ethnic landscape. It offers a culturally specific perspective that steers clear of Western-centric cinematic norms.

How does First, Second & Third Love represent religion and culture?

Fair

The narrative delves into the weight of familial duties and personal secrets. It avoids idealized family structures, instead presenting a more realistic view of domestic life.

Does First, Second & Third Love include disability representation?

Minimal

While the hospital setting suggests health challenges, there is no clear indication that disability is a central theme or that characters have specific roles or ability to act related to their conditions.

Present on Screen

Emphasizes emotional labor and caregiving, which may challenge traditional gender hierarchies.
Provides a culturally specific Indonesian perspective that avoids Western-centric norms.
Avoids idealized family structures, opting for a realistic view of domestic life and duty.

Limited or Absent

Lacks clear representation or narratives centered on non-traditional gender identities.
Does not provide clear evidence of characters with disabilities having specific roles or ability to act.
Misses opportunities for overt multi-layered subversion or radical social critiques.

Official Synopsis

While caring for their respective parents, Asia and Raja meet in a hospital and fall in love, but a bittersweet secret changes everything.

How are these scores produced? →