You are here:

Paternal Instinct

Name: Paternal Instinct
Director: Murray Nossel
Released: 2004
Duration: 75 min

Representation Score

6.5/10

Good

2004

Director

Murray Nossel

Runtime

75 minutes

Average Rating

No ratings yet

New Showbiz Analysis

Paternal Instinct stands out as a humanizing look at non-traditional family structures. By centering the journey of two gay men, the film moves beyond simple visibility to explore the biological and legal complexities of queer parenthood. The documentary succeeds in challenging standard Western hierarchies by integrating alternative spiritual identities, such as the Wiccan surrogate. This adds a layer of cultural complexity that challenges traditional domestic clichés. However, the film's focus remains heavily centered on the male protagonists, limiting the broader exploration of gender and ethnic diversity within the narrative.

Watch this, not that →

Category Breakdown

Does Paternal Instinct have LGBTQ+ representation?

Excellent

The film gives significant power to its central LGBTQ+ subjects, focusing on the real-life experiences of queer parenthood. It challenges the idea that everyone is straight by centering the story on two gay men navigating surrogacy.

How does Paternal Instinct portray gender?

Good

The story explores unconventional gender roles through reproductive technology. While the male protagonists drive the plot, the inclusion of a Wiccan surrogate introduces a feminine archetype outside traditional domestic clichés.

How racially and ethnically diverse is Paternal Instinct?

Fair

The narrative emphasizes subcultural identity through a surrogate from Maine. While specific ethnic compositions are not detailed, the film explores diversity through spiritual and lifestyle overlaps.

How does Paternal Instinct represent religion and culture?

Excellent

The film challenges singular Christian moral frameworks by introducing alternative spiritualities. It deconstructs sanitized family narratives by focusing on the complex, repetitive rituals of conception.

Does Paternal Instinct include disability representation?

Minimal

There is no evidence provided regarding the portrayal of physical or neurodivergent disabilities in this work.

Present on Screen

Gives significant power to LGBTQ+ subjects, framing their pursuit of parenthood as a proactive and sophisticated human endeavor.
Challenges traditional religious frameworks by incorporating alternative spiritual identities and non-traditional belief systems.
Challenges traditional family clichés through a nuanced exploration of the biological complexities of surrogacy.

Limited or Absent

The narrative focus remains heavily centered on the male protagonists, which limits the breadth of gender-based subversion.
The film lacks explicit detail regarding the racial and ethnic identities of the participants involved in the story.

Official Synopsis

In contrast to the recent spate of gay parent documentaries Paternal Instinct is a fascinating and absorbing insight into the breeding process. We follow two gay men in their search for a suitable surrogate mother, a Wiccan from Maine, and then the agonizing three year long process of trying to get her pregnant. There is the anguish as they discover the impotent link in the fathering chain, the comedy of the repetitive conception rituals and the ecstasy of the birth of their child. With unfettered access to the participants, Oscar-nominated filmmaker Murray Nossel charts every step, and the camera never flinches. Whether you're into the whole parenting thing or not, the sheer humanity of this piece makes it totally absorbing.

How are these scores produced? →